When smart people give you opposite advice


Hey Reader,

Have you ever asked so many questions you got kicked out of a store?

That’s what happened to Sam Walton. Before Walmart was what it is today, Sam would walk into stores owned by his competitors with a tape recorder. He studied how they ran everything and recorded conversations with anyone who would talk to him.

He asked so many questions he'd get thrown out.

Sam was relentlessly focused on what his competitors did best so he could do the same thing even better.

Recently on my podcast, I interviewed Will Guidara, author of Unreasonable Hospitality. If you don’t know Will, he's built a career out of turning what might have otherwise been an ordinary meal into an experience you’ll never forget.

He also studies his competition closely but does something very different from Sam:

Will ignores what his competitors do well and obsesses over what they do poorly.

So here we have two obviously smart people recommending different approaches.

One says to do what your competition does best but even better. The other says to ignore their strengths and focus on their weaknesses.

And that brings me to what I want to talk about today:

What do you do when smart people give you opposite advice?

This is something you’ll run into constantly in business (and as a human). You’re going to get conflicting advice from people you respect all of the time—either in person or online with people you follow.

The first thing is to get comfortable with that. Your job is to take those inputs and figure out what's right for you.

The second thing is to look for the layer underneath the conflict and ask yourself: Is there actually a conflict here? Are these two things truly opposed to each other?

In the case with Sam and Will, what they’re doing is quite similar. They just chose to solve for it a little differently. Both obsess over the customer experience, and both learn everything they can from their competition. They just point that obsession at different things.

We can get so caught up in trying to figure out which is the “right” advice to take when really the bigger, and much more common, issue is trying to do everything—or jump from thing to thing.

I see this happen a lot where someone hears they should focus on Instagram and then attends a mastermind where someone else shares how well they’re doing on LinkedIn, and they feel like they need to jump to that.

Oftentimes, following either one would have worked. It’s just that you didn’t focus and stick with it long enough.

For a lot of questions in life, there’s rarely one right answer.

The final lens I like to use is: Do I want to live the life they have?

I like to keep their life circumstances and experiences at the forefront of my mind and listen to their stories. Sometimes that can help you determine which advice to follow.

Smart people disagree all the time, and that's okay. Look for what’s underneath what they’re sharing. Pick one route and follow it long enough to tell whether it's working for you.


video preview​

PODCAST

I Asked a Speaking Coach to Roast My Biggest Speech

I know I had Mike Pacchione on the podcast last week to talk about how to take a talk from good to great.

But this is a second episode—and it's different.

I had Mike back on the show to roast the keynote talk I gave at Craft + Commerce.

We put the recording up to watch on the screen and stopped every time Mike saw something worth talking about.

You may have heard people give speaking advice before, but seeing a talk critiqued in real time with commentary from an expert coach will help you learn what makes a great talk in a whole new way.

Join me for a behind-the-scenes look at the biggest keynote I’ve ever delivered.

​Watch or listen to episode »​

KIT FEATURE

Reveal subscribers who can change your business

Your email list knows more about your audience than you think. Subscriber Signals surfaces the demographic and professional data behind your subscribers, so you can find your best leads, understand who your audience really is, and identify collaborators, all without the manual research.

  • Find warm leads: Filter by engagement, job title, company, and social reach to surface the people on your list most likely to buy
  • Understand your audience: Get a real demographic picture of your subscribers: income, age distribution, homeownership, and more
  • Build your sponsorship deck: Auto-generate a shareable media kit with live audience data to justify your rates to advertisers
  • Discover collaborators: Find affiliates, partners, and podcast guests who are already on your list

​Request access »​

X POST

"Things I'm not doing anymore"

This is a great list from Greg Eisenberg of things he says he's not doing anymore.

Among them:

  • refreshing analytics dashboards more than once a day
  • multitasking during family or friend time
  • comparing myself to others who are playing different games
  • keeping friendships going purely out of history instead of actual enjoyment

Read the full list here:

​View post »​

—Nathan

P.S.

I recently had a fun "how is this my life?" moment.

Last week on a whim, I flew over Idaho's Sawtooth Mountains at sunset and went to Redfish Lake. It was something I'd decided to do maybe 3 hours earlier.

And I just had this moment where I thought: I'm flying a plane that I own, with skills that I learned, going to one of my favorite places, and it's just a casual after-work thing.

When I landed the plane at a little grass runway up in the mountains, someone from the transportation department who maintains the runway asked if I'd been to Redfish Lake before.

Some quick mental math and I estimated I'd visited Redfish 30 of the last 36 years.

In this crazy world, doing all of these different things, it was really good to still feel grounded in my childhood, and who I am, and to spend some time in mountains I'd backpacked all over throughout my life.

Flying my plane
Plane on the grass runway
Walking alongside Redfish Lake
Flying back home over the Sawtooth Mountains

Nathan Barry

I'm a designer who turned into a writer who turned into a startup CEO. My mission is to help creators earn a living. Subscribe for essays on building an audience and earning a living as a creator.

Read more from Nathan Barry

Hey Reader, “You don’t own a jet, right?” That question was not directed at me. I was speaking at Main Street Summit recently, a conference for founders running $5 million to $50 million businesses, and I’d ended up in a group of people talking about airplanes. Three of us were pilots. A man walked up who everyone else seemed to know. Halfway through the conversation, one of the pilots turned and asked him about the jet. “No,” he said. “It annoys me how expensive it is, so I go back and forth...

Nathan’s visit to Harvard Business School

Hey Reader, Have you noticed house parties aren’t really a thing anymore? We’re spending more time at home than we used to and a lot of us don’t have as many hobbies as we did even a few years ago. My theory is that COVID is to blame and we never fully recovered from it. People share posts about this all the time, so it’s clearly something a lot of us are feeling. And I think what a lot of people do is complain that things aren’t the same anymore and then go back to living their lives. But...

video preview

Hey Reader, Wouldn’t it be nice to have more hours in a day to grow your business? I often find myself wishing I had more hours, too. But I have to remind myself that working more only gets me so far. If I work extra hours at Kit this week, I might increase the company’s output by 0.01%. That’s not very much at all. Working extra hours is a way to be more productive, but productivity and leverage are not the same thing. A couple months ago, someone on my team asked me what the difference was...